Kamala Harris vs Donald Trump: Who Will Be a Better President for Africa-US Relations?
Recent polls have revealed a surprising tie between U.S. presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump. Harris and Trump are neck and neck, each with 46% support among registered voters. This close race highlights the importance of their differing views on African foreign policy and its effects on U.S.-Africa relations.
Africa’s population is set to exceed 2.5 billion by 2050, making it a crucial player in global affairs. However, the U.S. has historically been less engaged with Africa, ranking second in the Lowy Institute’s Diplomacy Index. This underinvestment in diplomatic efforts raises questions about future economic and security ties with Africa.
ALSO READ: DISCUSSION: Is Donald Trump Good For Africa?
The approaches of Harris and Trump to Africa are starkly different, reflecting in their support bases. Harris garners strong support from younger voters, Black voters, and those with higher education. Trump, on the other hand, enjoys a lead among older and White voters. These demographic differences could profoundly influence U.S.-Africa relations, affecting trade, aid, and diplomatic strategies.
Key Takeaways
- Harris and Trump are virtually tied in recent polls for the U.S. presidency
- Africa’s population is projected to reach 2.5 billion by 2050
- The U.S. ranks high in diplomacy but lacks engagement with Africa
- Harris performs better among younger and diverse voters
- Trump leads among older and White voters
- The election outcome could reshape U.S.-Africa relations
The Current State of US-Africa Relations
US-Africa relations have undergone significant changes, influencing economic growth and global leadership. Africa’s role in American foreign policy has varied, often relegated after the Cold War era. Yet, the relationship remains crucial for both regions.
Historical Context of US Engagement with Africa
The United States has been a dominant force in African affairs. It stands as the largest single donor, providing $9.5 billion in humanitarian aid to Africa in 2023. This aid mainly supports “soft” projects, such as education and health, rather than infrastructure.
Recent Developments in US-Africa Diplomacy
Recent shifts have marked US-Africa relations. The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) grants tariff-free access to US markets for eligible African countries, enhancing trade. Yet, China has become a formidable competitor, investing $25.7 billion in African infrastructure in 2018, vastly outpacing the US’s $297 million.
Key Challenges Facing US-Africa Relations
Challenges currently affect Africa-US relations. These include:
- Balancing infrastructure investment with China’s growing influence
- Addressing conflicts and insurgencies across the continent
- Promoting human rights while maintaining strategic partnerships
- Adapting to changing global leadership dynamics
The 2024 US presidential election may alter US-Africa relations, with potential shifts in foreign policy priorities under new leadership.
Kamala Harris’s Background and African Connections
Kamala Harris, the first woman and person of color to become Vice President of the United States, represents a pivotal moment in American politics. Her parents, an Indian mother and a Jamaican father, have shaped her unique cultural identity. This blend of heritage marks a shift in the American political landscape, underscoring the complexities of racial identity.
Her path to the White House was marked by her experiences as a woman of color. At Howard University, a historically Black institution, she developed her leadership skills and deepened her connection to African American culture. This background has significantly influenced her policy-making and diplomatic approach, especially towards Africa.
In 2023, Harris embarked on a tour of Africa, visiting Ghana, Tanzania, and Zambia. During this trip, she unveiled plans for the Partnership for Digital Access in Africa. This initiative aims to connect one billion people to the internet by 2030. It highlights Harris’s commitment to technological advancement and economic growth in Africa.
“My mother would look at me and she’d say, ‘Kamala, you may be the first to do many things, but make sure you are not the last.'”
Harris’s African heritage and her recent engagement with African nations suggest a potential shift in US-Africa relations. Her personal connections to the continent, combined with her progressive policy stance, could foster more inclusive and collaborative partnerships between the United States and African countries.
Donald Trump’s Previous Approach to Africa
Donald Trump’s presidency introduced a new era in US-Africa relations. His “America First” foreign policy shifted how the US interacted with the continent. This shift had significant effects on diplomatic ties, aid programs, and trade relations.
America First Policy Impact
Trump’s America First stance led to major cuts in foreign aid and diplomatic budgets. This hit many African nations that depended on US support. The policy focused on domestic issues over international commitments.
| Policy Area | Trump’s Approach | Impact on Africa |
|---|---|---|
| Foreign Aid | Substantial cuts | Reduced support for development projects |
| Diplomacy | Budget reductions | Decreased US presence and influence |
| Immigration | Stricter policies | Limited opportunities for African immigrants |
Controversial Actions
Trump’s presidency was filled with controversial statements about African countries. These remarks damaged diplomatic relations and drew criticism from African leaders. His efforts to cut aid programs made US-Africa ties even more complicated.
Trump Administration Initiatives
Despite the challenges, the Trump administration started some initiatives for Africa. The US International Development Finance Corporation was created to counter China’s influence. The Prosper Africa initiative aimed to increase trade and investment between the US and African nations.
Trump’s approach to Africa reflected his broader America First agenda. It put domestic concerns before international engagement, changing US-Africa relations. These changes still shape foreign policy debates today.
Comparing Foreign Policy Priorities
The US presidential elections spotlight foreign policy priorities. Kamala Harris and Donald Trump offer unique visions for global leadership. A recent poll highlights Harris as the top choice for the Democratic nomination in a crisis scenario.
Harris, an expert from the Homeland Security and Intelligence Committees, champions national security. She has been a strong advocate for defending allies against Russian aggression and enjoys a robust relationship with Israel’s government.
Trump’s “America First” policy has raised concerns in Europe and Asia about trade threats. His handling of Taiwan has also sparked intense debate in foreign policy circles.
Voters’ concerns mirror the complexities of global affairs. In North Carolina, 73% deem national security crucial. Nationally, preventing terrorist attacks and curbing illegal drug flows are top long-term concerns.
| Issue | Republican Support | Democratic Support |
|---|---|---|
| National Security (NC) | 42% | 30% |
| Russia-Ukraine Conflict | 36% | 34% |
The upcoming election will significantly influence America’s global stance. It will affect international alliances, trade deals, and security partnerships.
Economic Relations and Trade Agreements
The future of US-Africa economic relations is uncertain as the 2024 election nears. Trade agreements and economic partnerships will be crucial for both Harris and Trump.
AGOA’s Uncertain Future
The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), a vital part of US-Africa trade, is at a crossroads. Its renewal, set for 2025, could significantly alter economic ties. AGOA has granted duty-free access to over 1,800 African products in the US, greatly enhancing trade.
Countering China’s Economic Influence
China’s economic presence in Africa far surpasses the US. In 2021, US-Africa trade was $44.9 billion, whereas China-Africa trade hit $254.3 billion. Both Harris and Trump must devise strategies to counter China’s expanding influence.
Potential New Trade Initiatives
New trade initiatives could be vital to strengthen US-Africa economic ties. Trump’s administration preferred bilateral agreements, targeting individual countries. Conversely, a Harris administration might favor multilateral frameworks, engaging with African nations as a collective.
| Approach | Trump | Harris |
|---|---|---|
| Trade Policy | Bilateral focus | Multilateral framework |
| Import Tax | 10% on all imports | No proposed changes |
| China Strategy | Up to 60% tax on Chinese imports | Diplomatic approach |
The global landscape is evolving, offering African nations diverse investment options. As US policies change, countries aligning with US economic and security goals may discover new opportunities in this shifting environment.
Security Cooperation and Peacekeeping Efforts
The security cooperation and peacekeeping efforts in Africa are undergoing significant changes. China has notably increased its involvement, sending 1,802 military and police personnel to UN peacekeeping missions. Meanwhile, Russia’s influence is growing, particularly through the Wagner Group. This development poses a challenge to the US’s security influence in the region.
Vice President Kamala Harris’s stance on international development and security cooperation might diverge from the current administration’s. Her emphasis on racial injustice and climate change could lead to a reorientation of US priorities in Africa. However, her limited interaction with key international leaders on critical security issues has raised concerns among critics.
The US is currently facing global security threats on a scale similar to those of 1945. With geopolitical tensions escalating, including Vladimir Putin’s actions in Europe, the necessity for effective peacekeeping efforts is evident. Future US administrations will need to navigate these evolving security dynamics and possibly reassess their peacekeeping strategies in Africa.
| Country | Peacekeeping Contribution | Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| China | 1,802 personnel | UN missions |
| Russia | Undisclosed | Wagner Group |
| US | Varies | Reassessment needed |
The global security landscape is changing, requiring the US to adjust its approach to security cooperation and peacekeeping in Africa. This adaptation is vital for maintaining influence and promoting stability in the region.
Kamala Harris or Donald Trump: Who Will Be Better President for Africa
The US presidential elections are intensifying, with Kamala Harris and Donald Trump at the forefront. Their potential influence on African foreign policy and economic growth is a significant concern.
Potential Policy Shifts under Harris
At 59, Harris introduces a new outlook on US-Africa relations. Her background hints at a deeper engagement with the continent. Polls indicate nearly half of Americans believe Harris is more dedicated to democracy than Trump. This could result in enhanced diplomatic connections with African countries.
Likely Continuation of Trump’s Approach
Trump’s “America First” policy might diminish US involvement in Africa. 45% of Americans trust Trump over Harris on economic matters. This could signify a decrease in US investments in African economic projects. Trump’s campaign emphasizes domestic issues, potentially overshadowing African concerns.
Impact on Key African Issues
Harris has an advantage over Trump on racial issues and healthcare, which could benefit African nations seeking US support. Trump’s stance on trade might impact existing agreements like AGOA. The poll reveals no clear national leader, hinting at uncertain times for US-Africa relations.
| Candidate | Median Polling Average | Potential Impact on Africa |
|---|---|---|
| Kamala Harris | 53.2% | Increased diplomatic engagement |
| Donald Trump | 46.8% | Focus on domestic issues |
The Role of US Aid and Development Programs in Africa
US aid is vital for international development in Africa. USAID leads in foreign assistance, focusing on education, health, and democratic governance. These efforts aim to enhance lives and stability in partner countries.
Recent shifts in US aid priorities are noteworthy. The Biden administration boosted the aid budget, yet foreign budgets now favor other regions over Africa. This trend could impact the scale of US programs on the continent.
Human rights promotion is a central focus of US aid. Yet, internal debates over sensitive topics can occur. For instance, in 2018, disagreements over gender equality assessments in Georgia led to two reports. One included abortion references, while the other did not.
| Administration | Aid Focus | Potential Impact on Africa |
|---|---|---|
| Biden | Increased budget, traditional programs | Continued support for existing initiatives |
| Trump (Potential) | Restructuring USAID, shift in priorities | Reduced focus on gender equality, changes in aid distribution |
Future administrations will grapple with balancing domestic needs with global development goals. This delicate balance will influence the future of US aid in Africa. It will affect areas like human rights promotion and democratic governance support.
Conclusion
The future of US-Africa relations is uncertain as the 2024 presidential race heats up. Kamala Harris and Donald Trump offer different visions for foreign policy, each with implications for Africa. Harris has a strong lead among Black, Hispanic, and young voters, showing her broad appeal.
Trump’s term saw limited focus on Africa, sparking worries about future ties if he wins again. The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) is set to end in 2025, highlighting the need for new economic agreements. The US is a key market for South African exports, making trade agreements crucial.
The election’s outcome will greatly influence US-Africa relations. Harris might bring a more inclusive stance, while Trump could focus on domestic issues. Regardless, US involvement in Africa’s security, especially against terrorism, will continue. The next president must tackle complex issues to strengthen ties with Africa in a changing world.
Responses